Golf in Shelter Island
Two relaxed island clubs reached by ferry from North Haven or Greenport.
Shelter Island Heights
Gardiner's Bay Country Club
PrivateGolf$$
Shelter Island's private club, overlooking Gardiner's Bay, with a hilly, scenic course and a relaxed island membership.
Getting in: Hard (sponsor needed)
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill)
Public9 holes$
Shelter Island's public nine, nicknamed Goat Hill for its steep, rocky terrain and blind shots, with harbor views from the clubhouse deck.
Getting in: Walk-on easy
| Club | Town | Type | Holes | Cost | Getting in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gardiner's Bay Country Club | Shelter Island Heights | Private | – | $$ | Hard (sponsor needed) (7/10) |
| Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill) | Shelter Island Heights | Public | 9 | $ | Walk-on easy (1/10) |