Home / Clubs / Shelter Island
Shelter Island HeightsGardiner's Bay Country Club
Shelter Island's private club, overlooking Gardiner's Bay, with a hilly, scenic course and a relaxed island membership.
| Type | Private |
|---|---|
| Location | Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 |
| Area | Shelter Island |
| Holes | – |
| Par | – |
| Founded | 1895 |
| Architect | – |
| Cost level | $$ |
| Getting in | Hard (sponsor needed) (7/10) |
What it costs
| Initiation (reported) | Not published. |
|---|---|
| Annual dues (reported) | Not published |
| Daily play | Members and their guests only |
Private clubs don't publish fees. These figures come from press reports and can be years old; see our membership cost guide for sources and context.
How hard is it to get in?
7/10 · Hard (sponsor needed). Member sponsorship; island homeowners make up much of the membership.
How to play it as a guest
Member-guest only. For public island golf, see Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill).
Worth knowing
- Island club with bay views
Public courses nearby
Can't get an invitation? These are open to everyone:
- Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill) (Shelter Island Heights)
- Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course (Montauk)
- Sag Harbor State Golf Course (Sag Harbor)
FAQ
Can I play Gardiner's Bay Country Club without being a member?
Generally only as a member's guest. Member-guest only. For public island golf, see Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill).
How much does it cost to join Gardiner's Bay Country Club?
Not published. Annual dues: Not published.
How hard is it to get into Gardiner's Bay Country Club?
We rate it 7/10 (hard (sponsor needed)). Member sponsorship; island homeowners make up much of the membership.
More in Shelter Island
Shelter Island Country Club (Goat Hill)
Shelter Island's public nine, nicknamed Goat Hill for its steep, rocky terrain and blind shots, with harbor views from the clubhouse deck.
Spot an error? Clubs and readers can send corrections to scott@appliedresults.com.